Detroit Become Human Vs Until Dawn

• For information on humanitarian relief/back up efforts for Ukraine, and how you can help, delight visit this thread.

You are using an out of appointment browser. Information technology may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

• #1

Equally the thread title says, these two games should FIGHT. I only got Until Dawn 2 nights ago from Gamefly and I'm on chapter 4 at present, I'm and so impressed at the game. It captures the "teen horror" movie cliche stuff so well. It also looks phenomenal. I'g however dazzled at how it plays so much like those types of movies.

I completed Detriot when it released a couple months ago and even though I throughly enjoyed information technology, playing Until Dawn now has somewhat made me reevaluate Detriot game play wise. David Cage tries so hard to turn his games into a film experience a lot of the controls feel somewhat unintuitive. Until Dawn didnt try to hide the fact that information technology was more of a passive experience than an active one; It gave the user control over well-nigh situations but during fast segments, the game relies on quicktime events which helps keep the action moving while remaining cinematic. Cage's game tries too hard to give yous control of limbs etc while the action is moving and it deters from the activity of the game.

I added the TellTale games in hither too simply their style of doing a game was fine last generation but I truly experience like Until Dawn should get the standard. The last TellTale game I played and actually enjoyed was The Wolf Amid U.s.. I know those games tend to lean towards old style point and click adventures but the way their current games are set feels archaic in nature. They tin can go on the artifacts they desire the players to notice while truly pushing that cinematic route. Correct now it feels like their mixing point and clicks and story games but it still feels bad-mannered in a lot of places.

I'm simply super impressed at Until Dawn. I had my wife watching me and she got into information technology too and she enjoyed watching me play Detriot as well merely she said there something nearly Until Dawn that just plays well with the genre they picked.

I know they announced another series of games in an anthology, I'm now super pumped for it.

Edit: If a mod can edit the title, meant Detroit Become Human

• #2

Until Dawn > Walking Dead > Detroit > Also Man

• #3

In terms of the actual story and characters information technology would be The Walking Dead Season one > Until Dawn > Detroit Become Human

• #5

Until Dawn is the top of this mode of gamble games.

I am stoked to see the devs go third party and brand more than instead of making VR games.

• #half-dozen

They are all not bad except for Detroit, which is like a parody on racial tensions.

• #seven

Until Dawn > Everything else

• #viii

In terms of the actual story and characters it would be The Walking Dead Flavour 1 > Until Dawn > Detroit Get Human

I loved the Walking Expressionless flavour one, but Until Dawn is on a different level. At their core they're very different games, but Supermassive really plays with the genre in a way that compliments the game and then well. The story in the first flavour of walking dead is truly spectacular but the gameplay of those games agree them back from being more than.

• #nine

Detroit > Until Dawn >>>> Telltales

Until dawn is a bit lower because of the later chapters

Super natural shits and not so much unlike endings

• #11

The first Walking Dead season is still probably my favorite Telltale game and ahead of both of these games by a land mile. The Writing in that game is so many leagues ahead of Until Dawn and specially Detroit it'southward non even a contest to exist honest. For me, the most important matter near these games is how much I enjoyed the characters and the story. And very few games had the emotional impact on me that TWD'due south 1 ending did. It was likewise pretty revolutionary for the whole genre.

How many decisions I tin can make barely makes a dent in my enjoyment and the fact that I go like a million versions of desperately written characters in Detroit doesn't really assist the game at all imo. In the example of Until Dawn I merely never fell in honey with it. I though it was kinda fun at times, reaaaaally boring at times and just largely unnoteworthy.

For me:

The Walking Expressionless (and also Tales of the Borderlands considering holy shit how is that game and then good) >>>>UntilDawn>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >Detroit

• #12

Detroit>>>>>Walking Dead>Until Dawn

Detroit was special.

• #13

I'd put Detroit above Until Dawn simply considering of its over-reliance on jump scares and fake choices make information technology hard to replay. But it's still a peachy fantastic must play game that captures the tension and feeling of that kind of horror picture perfectly.

Detroit has some crazy variation in how things can change on different playthroughs. And putting how extrmely OTT exploititive of current racial tensions and on the olfactory organ information technology was, is very well written and produced story.

• #14

I put the walking expressionless at acme mainly because its the nigh well written of the batch. Until Dawn is a shut second and I besides like it a lot, merely the shenanigans related to Matt and Jess and motion controls keeps it from beingness meliorate. Detroit while impressive on a technical level gets really stupid and insulting between plot shenanigans and handling of the more sensitive subjects. Conner'south portions are the only parts that are consistently proficient.

• #15

Edit: If a mod can edit the title, meant Detriot: Become Man

Think you also meant Detroit, non Detriot.

• #16

Until Dawn is the well-nigh realized and perfected 1 of them all.

What I would practise for a "The Affair" game using the same tech and made by the same developer...

• #17

In terms of story/characters I would say TWD > Detroit > Until Dawn. In terms of branching narrative, which kinda is the indicate of these games it's Detroit >>>>>> Until Dawn >> Walking Expressionless. Engineering wise it's Detroit > Until Dawn >>>> TWD

• #eighteen

Detroit > Until Dawn > The Walking Dead

• #19

Until Dawn = The Walking Dead >>>>>>>>>>>>> Detroit: Become Human.

If Detroit: Go Human being was just Hank and Connor, it'd be a lot closer but as information technology is, it's maybe 1/3rd to 1/two an enjoyable game. Supermassive managed to beat David Cage at his own game (and this is from someone who has a fondness for Fahrenheit and Heavy Rain) on their first try. Despite the similarities, The Walking Dead is a chip hard to judge against the other ii. Until Dawn was more than entertaining, but The Walking Dead (season one at least) was more than emotional.

• #20

Detroit overtook Until Dawn for me. Every bit much every bit I enjoy UD, some of the outcomes are and so arbitrarily adamant, the flare gun being the biggest offender, information technology ruins some of the mystique. Detroit has a lot more branching and variation in how things tin play out. I'm excited to meet what Supermassive can do after all these years since UD has released.

• #21

It's a masterpiece and the most emotional between the rest.. I take no thought how they accept pulled the game out with all these many choices and outcomes... David Cage is a bright man.

• #23

Detroit>Until Dawn>> Walking Dead.

Detroit should become the standard past which these types of games are compared to. But simply the best gameplay with branching narratives.

• #24

I practice agree regarding Detroit's branching paths, it'southward very impressive, and Until Dawn already shows its paw at certain aspects of the game, but it'south still told very well and is entertaining as heck. I do as well recollect the genre has a lot to practice with information technology besides.

• #25

Boy would I love for Until Dawn to accept reward of the Pro. It's such a brilliant game that apparently needs only a little more power to push those visuals. Until Dawn with a smooth frame rate would be a dream come truthful.

• #26

Until Dawn = The Walking Dead >>>>>>>>>>>>> Detroit: Become Homo.

If Detroit: Go Human being was just Hank and Connor, it'd exist a lot closer but as it is, information technology's peradventure 1/3rd to 1/2 an enjoyable game. Supermassive managed to vanquish David Muzzle at his own game (and this is from someone who has a fondness for Fahrenheit and Heavy Rain) on their first effort. Despite the similarities, The Walking Dead is a bit hard to judge against the other 2. Until Dawn was more entertaining, but The Walking Dead (flavor one at least) was more emotional.

Detroit and Until Dawn kinda have dissimilar goals in terms of branching narrative. Detroit is way more ambitious and better realized in that regard, no one really has Detroit beat in that attribute. I would estimate information technology has like two-iii times the amount of content as Until Dawn. In that respect it is the gold standard pretty much. While enjoyment is plain subjective, I would also say Detroit has a vastly more ambitious game design with capacity like Fugitives, where you have to act in a miniature sandbox and have truthful liberty where to become. Or stuff like chase scenes giving yous a lot of control. All while the game also attempts to simulate a breathing urban center with various settings, NPC and traffic simulations and so on. Until Dawn simply really has QTE mode and bones exploration mode. No real switch up happens and the scope is small without whatever complicated ecology scripting. It is effective, just much simpler. Not saying complicated is amend, merely as I said at the beginning the ambitions and goals are kinda unlike.

• #27

Fifty-fifty though the writing's not that good imo, Detroit is the first game that truly delivers on the "every choice matters" and "create your ain story" line.

• #28

Until Dawm is the ameliorate of them all.
Choices matter more than.

• #30

Why TWD? There's better games from Telltale than it.

• #31

If Detroit had amend writing and lacked the quintessential David Cage things (like washing the dishes, turning on the lights, etc.), information technology would exist such a adept game and mode better than Until Dawn. I will never terminate shilling Detroit's OST.
But Detroit's writing has obvious problems (welcome to the Civil Rights Motion AND the end of slavery! at the same fourth dimension! but robots!)
So Until Dawn is better. The pacing and fun factor are leagues beyond Detroit.
Also I haven't played TWD so no comment.

• #32

Why TWD? At that place'due south amend games from Telltale than information technology.

True simply its essential the game that got them on the map. I personally recollect Wolf Among U.s. is their all-time game.

• #33

Until Dawn.

I loved TWD season 1 until i discovered its shitty background fob choices.

Bricktop

Attempted to circumvent ban with an alt account

• #34

Until Dawn was probably my biggest surprise of this generation. It's such an excellent game that captures the horror movie experience perfectly. I wish we'd go another 1.

• #35

I oasis't even played the other 2 (Until Dawn and Detroit) and I tin already tell you lot information technology ain't TWD, or whatever Telltale game for that thing. Their games are laughable in comparing in terms of branching narrative with choices and consequence.

• #36

Detroit>Walking Expressionless>Until Dawn

Detroit has problems with its writing but ultimately the branching paths and it's characters put this above the other ii for me. Until Dawn is but a really fun time just I wasn't likewise fond of where the plot went in the second one-half. Walking Dead is merely a cracking grapheme driven story but similar all Telltale games, your choices mean zip and in this genre it kind of supposed to be one if its features.

• #37

I haven't played whatever of them except for TWD S1. Too bad The Wolf Among Us or Life is Foreign aren't on the list

• #38

Until Dawn > Walking Dead > Detroit > Too Human

First post nails information technology for me.

I idea Until Dawn was fantastic. Played through it with my wife next to me and nosotros both loved information technology. Thought Detroit was trash.

• #39

They are so unlike that I really can't compare them.

The Walking Dead is an emotional investment that none of those games compare to (the closest thing in that genre would be Life is Strange) with a powerful story that is told well. Detroit has the best presentation, the best acting, the best soundtrack, etc. It is probably the all-time overall bundle - and Connor is my favorite graphic symbol from all 3 games, probably. Until Dawn is pure fun and something I tin can replay over and once more.

• #twoscore

I've only played Until Dawn of the three (although did play Heavy Pelting) and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I only played it because I had just bought a PS4, it was free on PS+, and none of my games had arrived yet, and it's been the most surprised I've been over the quality of a game so far.

Something that people have mentioned in the thread, which is a off-white criticism. is that the choices don't really matter. I matter which the game actually succeeds at in my opinion is giving you the illusion that they practice. The butterfly and idol systems were very clever in my opinion because of how much weight they added to all of the choices in the game and really built up tension effectually what you were doing (while as well fitting very well into the type of horror trope the game was paying homage to). Even though most of the 'correct' choices aren't particularly difficult to identify, it's all the same exciting in the moment and this is compounded by the social stats (even though if I recollect correctly they exercise very niggling). Although Heavy Rain probably had more branching options overall (and some more pregnant ones), I came away from Until Dawn thinking its choices mattered to a much greater deal and had more significance. On a replay information technology becomes clear how there are really very few major choices, only on an initial playthrough the game was designed in a very clever way to brand it feel similar choices were very important.

Bated from the effect its choices had on the experience, I really enjoyed how well information technology worked with the 'teen horror/slasher' formula. Information technology was a really effective blazon of story to target with this fashion of gameplay and the writing is very practiced at capturing the type of motion-picture show it'south playing-off. The pacing was actually skillful, and it was a huge amount of fun on a first playthrough. I've heard it makes a really practiced political party game (with different people decision-making dissimilar characters), and I'd accept loved to have been able to play it for the get-go time with a grouping of people.

• #41

It's Detroit past a mile. The amount of choice and upshot and variables blow the others out of the water, while also cleverly giving you control during sequences while still maintaining that branching nature

Walking Dead has the nigh emotional and compelling story but the actual design feels outdated compared to Detroit

Oct 27, 2017

22,189

Derry

• #42

Until Dawn > The Walking Dead > Detroit: Become Man

But I liked all 3 quite a bit

• #43

For me it goes Detroit > Until Dawn >>>>> TWD. I just love the futuristic setting of Detroit over the slasher-flick setting of Until Dawn merely really they're both excellent games.

• #44

Detroit > The Walking Expressionless: Season ane > Until Dawn.

• #45

Detroit was by the far the all-time in opinion, I tin't play Until Dawn because I can't stand horror games, and The Walking Dead was good

• #46

I haven't played Detroit, but unless information technology'southward leagues across Heavy Pelting, Indigo Prophecy, and Beyond Two Souls, my judge is that I'd probably put it at the bottom.

David Cage'southward games oft suffer from existence mediocre-to-decent narrative experiences that don't seem content with existence narrative experiences and therefore force yous every so oftentimes to engage with absolute shit gameplay. Until Dawn and TWD both limit their gameplay interactions to meaningful events. Quantic Games is still hither throwing in shoe-horned action set pieces that are lame as fuck to play.

• #47

Detroit>Until Dawn>TWD

I really do dearest them all, UD is i of my faves, loved TWD back in the day, but human being... I am OBSESSED with Detroit. I can't stop thinking about it, reading things about it, finding out more than things that can change in the game (FOR EXAMPLE:

it blew my mind when I establish out recently that depending on what happens in Connor's first scene, he might exist afraid of heights near the 3/4th mark of the game. Or that even if yous don't deviate Connor in his big selection scene, he can technically still deviate in the ending.

I loved all the characters in the game, the story, the music. I tin can't get over it and I'm having i of those post-game-tin't-give-this-upward hard time moving on from it.

• #48

Until Dawn has Emily. Until Dawn ever wins unless you lot want to understand the palm of her hand.

Edit: I volition say that the Conner and Hank stuff was really good and if Detroit had been nigh merely them it would have been improve.

• #49

I oasis't played Detroit, but unless it's leagues across Heavy Rain, Indigo Prophecy, and Beyond Two Souls, my guess is that I'd probably put it at the bottom.

David Cage'south games ofttimes suffer from existence mediocre-to-decent narrative experiences that don't seem content with being narrative experiences and therefore force yous every so often to engage with absolute shit gameplay. Until Dawn and TWD both limit their gameplay interactions to meaningful events. Quantic Games is nevertheless here throwing in shoe-horned action set pieces that are lame as fuck to play.

Detroit certainly is the best of them all. But it still tries to insert as much gameplay as it can, more successfully than the by attempts I may add together, but it is probably subjective if y'all like it or non. I personally like that QD isn't simply throwing their hands into the air and just have the most bare minimum of interaction.

• #50

Don't let OP distract y'all from the fact that Telltale's Batman: The Enemy Within is one of their all-time seasons however.

Source: https://www.resetera.com/threads/until-dawn-vs-detriot-too-human-vs-walking-dead-fight.66047/

Share this post